Tower Action Group Tower Action Group

Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Who are TAG?
A: The Tower Action Group are a group of local residents who are concerned about the number of mobile phone masts being placed near to homes, schools and hospitals. We are particularly concerned about the Gorsehill Water Tower which currently has 20 antennae on it and is less than 200 meters from two primary schools.
 
Q: Why are you opposed to mobile phones?
A: We are not opposed to mobile phones. Many of us have mobile phones ourselves. We are opposed to the placement of mobile phone masts so close to where people live and work.
 
Q: What's wrong with mobile phone masts? TV and radio antennae have been around for 80 years without causing any problems.
A: TV and radio antennae are analogue and send out a continuous signal. Powerful transmitters may use hundreds of thousands of watts and it is well known that such large amounts of power can burn or even kill. No one is allowed near these antennae without special training and safety precautions.

Mobile phone masts, on the other hand, use only tens of watts of power and so generate very little heat. It is assumed that they must be safe.

This, however, overlooks the fact that mobile phones work in a completely different way to TV and radio. Mobile phones are digital and send their signal as a series of pulses. It is thought that this pulsing can interfere with the natural rhythms of body cells and of the nervous system.

An analogy may be made with visible light. The full power of the sun can burn while the light from lightbulbs is harmless. However a flickering bulb can cause fits in some epileptics.

Unfortunately, the research into mobile phone radiation is still being carried out. No one can say who, if anyone, is affected by it or what may happen to them. Until we know, the only safe thing to do is to use the precautionary principle and place the masts away from people.

Children have thinner skulls and a developing nervous system, so if there are any effects from mobile phone radiation, they could be most pronounced in them. The government has used this argument to recommend that children limit their use of mobile phones, yet still allows masts to be placed in schools.

 
Q: The masts have got to go somewhere. Aren't you being a bit NIMBY?
A: The masts have a range of up to 30km. They could be placed in the docks area of Liverpool away from housing and schools. There are also plans for several wind farms in Liverpool Bay and there is no technical reason why they could not be placed out there. Antennae can also be shared by mobile phone companies, but there is little or no incentive for them to do so.

Unfortunately, the planning law does not allow you to suggest other locations. The council can only make a refuse/accept decision.

 
Q: Why use the Water Tower then?
A: It is much cheaper than having to build a new mast somewhere else and electricity is already laid on. The owners of the Water Tower (Fields and Towers?) have a duty to their shareholders to maximise their profits and so are happy to receive about five thousand pounds for each mast.
 
Q: Are there any other issues?
A: The Gorsehill Water Tower is a Grade II listed building, a fine example of Victorian architecture. We believe that there should be no disfigurement to the original building and that all existing additions should be removed.

Many resident remember when the Tower used to be open to visitors and the magnificent views of Liverpool Bay and the surroundings from one of the highest points in Wallasey. Perhaps the mobile phone masts could be removed and the Tower turned into an asset to the community?

 
Q: Can you provide a letter of objection to the phone masts?
A: The easiest way of objecting to the mobile phone masts is to sign the petition available in shops and churches. If we provided a "copy and send" form letter, your letter will go straight into the parliamentary bin, counting less than a petition signature.

However if you feel there are any particular issues you would like to raise then contact detail are available here.

 
Author: Tower Action Group <tag at emit.demon.co.uk>
Modified: 2003-03-28 15:16:06